Murder Mystery Games Comparison 2025: The Best Games for Home
Looking for a murder mystery game for home? In this comparison, we present 10 different providers - from box sets to digital downloads (incl. AI generator). This comparison helps you find the perfect murder mystery game for your group.
What is a Murder Mystery Game for Home?
A murder mystery game for home is an interactive party game where you and your guests take on the roles of suspects and solve a murder case together. During a multi-course dinner, you collect clues, question each other, and try to unmask the murderer.
The market for murder mystery games has grown significantly in recent years. Basically, there are two main categories:
Box Sets
Pre-made games to unpack and play immediately with physical materials
Digital Content
PDF files for printing or playable online on your smartphone.
In this murder mystery games comparison 2025, we present 10 different providers and show you which game fits your needs.
⚖️ Legal Notice
Disclaimer: This comparison is based on our research and experience at the time of publication (November 2025). Prices, features, and availability may change. The ratings represent our subjective assessment and do not replace legal advice.
Conflict of Interest: Crime & Dine .io is a product of our company. We have tried to evaluate all providers fairly and objectively. In evaluating Crime & Dine .io, we focused on verifiable facts.
Trademark Rights: All brand names mentioned are the property of their respective owners. This comparison is for informational purposes only.
Purchase Criteria: What Should You Look For?
Before we get to the individual providers, here are the most important criteria for purchasing a murder mystery game:
Number of Players
Most murder mystery games are designed for 4-10 players. Make sure the game fits your group size. Some providers (e.g., Cocolino) even offer games for up to 60 people.
Personalization
Consider whether you prefer a pre-made game or would rather have influence on the game and characters yourself, for example to tailor it to you and your group.
Price-Performance
Prices range from €11.96 to €35 (premium box sets). Tip: Calculate the price per player - often a seemingly expensive game is cheaper per person. All prices are starting prices based on current research (as of: November 2025).
Availability
Digital content is usually available immediately, while box sets can have 2-5 days delivery time. If you plan short-term, digital options are often the better choice.
Available Languages
Most German providers offer their games only in German.Culinario Mortale also offers English, French, and Japanese (not all versions available in Germany).Crime & Dine .io is the first AI generator for murder mystery games and offers all content in German, English, French, and Spanish. If you're looking for a game in another language, check the available language versions directly on the providers' websites before purchasing.
Our Comparison - The Best Murder Mystery Games for Home
Each of the following providers has its own strengths and is suitable for different needs and preferences.
Crime & Dine .io
Crime & Dine .io is the first and currently only AI generator for murder mystery games. Each game is individually created using AI and is therefore unique. The platform enables you to generate personalized murder mystery games for 4-10 players.
Available Languages
German, English, French, Spanish - Crime & Dine .io is multilingual and offers all content in four languages. You can generate your murder mystery game in the language of your choice.
Advantages
- Personalization: Each murder mystery game is individually created using AI - tailored to your group and your setting
- No Spoilers: The murderer remains secret even for the creator - you can play along without knowing the solution
- Available Immediately: Generated in 15 minutes - no waiting time, no shipping
- Price: €2.99 per player - in the lower price segment
Disadvantages
- No physical box - less tactile for some players
- The number of players is limited to max. 10 players.
Who is it suitable for?
Crime & Dine .io is suitable for groups looking for a personalized murder mystery game. Suitable for:
- • Groups that value personalization and individuality
- • Short-term planning (available immediately, no waiting time)
- • Groups up to 10 people
- • Players who don't need physical materials
Culinario Mortale
Culinario Mortale is one of the most established providers of murder mystery box sets in Germany. With over 10 different themes, Culinario offers a wide selection of pre-made murder mystery games. Customer reviews praise the logical case resolution and good suitability for beginners.
Available Languages
German, English, French, Japanese - Culinario Mortale offers its games in multiple languages.Important: Not all language versions are available in Germany. Currently, only the German version is available through the German online shop. For other language versions, contact the manufacturer directly.
Advantages
- Large theme selection (10+ different games)
- High-quality physical box with all materials
- Proven stories with positive reviews
- Roles can be adjusted from male to female
Disadvantages
- Pre-made story (no personalization)
- Higher price than digital content (from €22.95 vs. from €11.96)
- Waiting time due to shipping (3-5 days)
- Fixed number of players (5-8 people) - less flexible than digital alternatives
Who is it suitable for?
Perfect for groups who prefer a classic box with physical materials and are willing to pay a bit more and wait for delivery.
Deadly Dinner (Pegasus Spiele)
Deadly Dinner from the renowned Pegasus Verlag offers high-quality murder mystery games with an innovative concept: Players receive secret envelopes in each round with physical objects and new clues. The 3-round system creates special tension and a tactile experience. The games take you to various settings like Hollywood ("Red Carpet to Ruin") and offer detailed character descriptions.
Available Languages
German - Deadly Dinner offers its games primarily in German. Some titles may also be available in English - please check availability directly on the provider's website.
Advantages
- Innovative 3-round system with physical evidence
- High-quality materials from the renowned Pegasus Verlag
- Detailed character descriptions and exciting plot
- Playing time 3-4 hours for an extensive evening
Disadvantages
- Pre-made story (no personalization)
- Higher price than digital content
- Delivery time 2-4 days
- Limited flexibility in number of players
Who is it suitable for?
Perfect for players who value tactile materials and an innovative game concept. Ideal for groups who prefer a structured 3-round system and are willing to wait for delivery.
Kosmos Krimidinner (Murder Mystery Party)
Kosmos is one of the most renowned game publishers in Germany and offers high-quality murder mystery boxes with the "Murder Mystery Party" series. Well-known titles such as "Deadly Wine", "Murderous Class Reunion", "Murder at the Grill", "Pasta & Pistols" and "Cocktail Mortale" cover various themes. The boxes contain detailed character descriptions, clues, invitation cards, recipes, and decoration tips. Some titles also offer accompanying audio material for an even more atmospheric evening.
Available Languages
German - Kosmos offers its murder mystery games in German.
Advantages
- Renowned publisher with proven quality
- Many different themes (wine, class reunion, grill, pasta, cocktail)
- Comprehensive material (characters, clues, recipes, decoration)
- Partially with audio material for more atmosphere
Disadvantages
- Pre-made story (no personalization)
- Fixed number of players (6-8) - less flexible
- Delivery time 2-4 days
- Price varies by title (from €24.99)
Who is it suitable for?
Ideal for groups who rely on proven quality from a renowned publisher and want to try different themes. Perfect for players who value comprehensive material and partial audio support.
Mörderische Dinnerparty
Mörderische Dinnerparty offers premium box sets with audio CD support. A detective guides you through the game, creating a particularly immersive experience. The games take you to various eras and settings such as the 1920s, the Orient, or Alpine glow. Comprehensive accessories including menu suggestions and recipes make the evening authentic.
Available Languages
German - Mörderische Dinnerparty offers its murder mystery games in German.
Advantages
- Audio CD with detective guides through the game
- High-quality premium equipment
- Many different themes (1920s, Orient, Alps)
- Menu suggestions and recipes included
Disadvantages
- Price in the upper segment (from €22.95)
- Pre-made story (no personalization)
- Delivery time 3-5 days
- CD player or playback device required
Who is it suitable for?
Ideal for groups looking for a particularly immersive experience with audio support and willing to invest more. Perfect for players who appreciate authentic settings with matching menu suggestions.
Masters of Mystery
Masters of Mystery offers digital murder mystery games that can be played both online (Zoom) and on-site. The games cover various eras - from the 1920s through the 1980s to the Wild West. Particularly suitable for large groups up to 18 people and remote teams who want to investigate together via video chat.
Available Languages
German - Masters of Mystery offers its murder mystery games in German.
Advantages
- Flexible: Online or for printing
- Suitable for large groups up to 18 people
- Many different themes (1920s, 1980s, Western)
- Available immediately as download
Disadvantages
- Price in the mid-range (from €29.95)
- Pre-made stories (no personalization)
- Need to print yourself
- For online play: Zoom account and technical equipment required
Who is it suitable for?
Ideal for remote teams who want to play online via Zoom, or for large groups on-site. Perfect for players who prefer proven, pre-made stories and are willing to invest more.
Cocolino Spieleverlag
Cocolino Spieleverlag is the specialist for very large groups. As the only provider, Cocolino offers murder mystery games for up to 60 people - ideal for corporate events, large celebrations, or club events. Various formats are available: classic murder mystery games, party formats, and special large group variants.
Available Languages
German - Cocolino Spieleverlag offers its murder mystery games in German.
Advantages
- Unique: Up to 60 players possible
- Various formats (classic, party, large groups)
- Available immediately as download
- Ideal for corporate events and large celebrations
Disadvantages
- Pre-made stories (no personalization)
- Price variable (often higher for large groups)
- Need to print yourself
- For very large groups: organization more complex
Who is it suitable for?
Perfect for corporate events, large celebrations, or club events with 15+ people. The only option for groups over 10 people looking for a structured murder mystery experience.
KRIMI total
KRIMI total has been on the market since 2004 and now offers 23 different murder mystery games with various themes. From 1920s glamour to modern settings, there's something for every taste. The free app supports the gaming experience, and additional materials such as recipes and name tags are included.
Available Languages
German - KRIMI total offers its murder mystery games in German.
Advantages
- Established since 2004 - proven quality
- 23 different games with wide theme selection
- Free app for support
- Additional materials (recipes, name tags) included
Disadvantages
- Interface seems somewhat outdated
- Pre-made stories (no personalization)
- Price variable (not always transparent)
- Need to print yourself
Who is it suitable for?
Good for players looking for a large selection of proven stories and who value additional materials. Established brand with years of experience.
krimidinner.party
krimidinner.party offers digital murder mystery games that can be played both online (Zoom) and on-site. The special feature: Escape game elements are integrated into the games, providing additional tension and variety. Flexible concept for various group sizes from 4 to 18 people.
Available Languages
German - krimidinner.party offers its games in German. According to our research, English versions may also be available - please check the availability directly on the provider's website.
Advantages
- Escape game elements integrated
- Flexible: Online (Zoom) or on-site
- For various group sizes (4-18)
- Available immediately as download
Disadvantages
- Pre-made stories (no personalization)
- Price variable (not always transparent)
- Need to print yourself
- For online play: Zoom and technical equipment needed
Who is it suitable for?
Ideal for remote teams who want to play online, or for groups who appreciate escape game elements. Good option for hybrid formats.
Parameter B
Parameter B offers murder mystery games as downloads with various thematic settings. The games are immediately available and can be used flexibly for different group sizes. For more information, visit parameter-b.de.
Available Languages
German - Parameter B offers its murder mystery games in German.
Advantages
- Thematic recipes matching the setting
- Unusual themes (Safari, Orient, Oktoberfest, Vampire)
- Good price (from €24.95)
- Available immediately as download
Disadvantages
- Pre-made stories (no personalization)
- Fixed number of players (8-12) - less flexible
- Need to print yourself
- Niche for special settings - limited selection
Who is it suitable for?
Perfect for groups who appreciate unusual themes and authentic, thematic recipes. Ideal for players looking for a complete experience with matching menu.
Comparison Table: All 10 Providers at a Glance
| Provider | Type | Price | Players | Language | Special Feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crime & Dine .io | Download + App (AI Generator) | from €11.96 | 4-10 | DE, EN, FR, ES | Personalized, unique, instant |
| Culinario Mortale | Box Set | from €22.95 | 5-8 | DE, EN, FR, JP* | 10+ themes, high-quality |
| Deadly Dinner | Box Set | from €29.95 | 4-8 | German | Secret envelopes |
| Kosmos Murder Mystery | Box Set | from €24.99 | 6-8 | German | Renowned publisher |
| Mörderische Dinnerparty | Box + CD | from €22.95 | 6-10 | German | Audio CD, Premium |
| Masters of Mystery | Download | from €29.95 | 4-18 | German | Online/Offline |
| Cocolino | Download | variable | 4-60 | German | Large groups |
| KRIMI total | Download + App | variable | variable | German | 23 games |
| krimidinner.party | Download | variable | 4-18 | German | Zoom-compatible |
| Parameter B | Download | from €24.95 | 4-12 | German | Thematic recipes |
Language Legend: DE = German, EN = English, FR = French, ES = Spanish, JP = Japanese
* Culinario Mortale: Not all language versions are available in Germany. Currently, only the German version is available through the German online shop.
Box Set vs. Digital Content - Which is Better?
Box Set
Advantages
- • Physical materials
- • Tactile experience
- • Proven stories
- • Beautiful gift box
Disadvantages
- • Pre-made (not personalized)
- • More expensive (from €18.47-€35)
- • Delivery time 2-5 days
- • Less flexible
Best choice for: Traditional players who prefer a physical box and are willing to pay more.
Digital Content
Advantages
- • Available immediately (no shipping)
- • Often large selection
- • Suitable for large groups
- • Flexible: Playable online (Zoom) or on-site
- • Cheaper than box sets
Disadvantages
- • Pre-made (not personalized)
- • Need to print yourself
- • Mid-priced (from €19.99-€27.85)
- • No physical materials
Best choice for: Large groups, remote teams, or players who want to get started immediately and don't need physical materials.
Which Murder Mystery Game Fits You?
You want a personalized experience?
→ Crime & Dine .io is the first and currently only AI generator for murder mystery games. Each game is individually created using AI and is therefore unique. Available in German, English, French, and Spanish.
Create Personalized Murder Mystery Game Now →You want a classic box to touch?
→ Culinario Mortale or Deadly Dinner offer high-quality physical box sets with proven stories.
You have a very large group (15+ people)?
→ Cocolino Spieleverlag specializes in large groups up to 60 people.
You want to play online via Zoom?
→ krimidinner.party or Masters of Mystery offer special online formats.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best murder mystery game for home?
The choice of the right murder mystery game depends on your individual preferences. Crime & Dine .io is the only option that creates each game individually and personalized - from €11.96 for 4 players. For classic box lovers, Culinario Mortale or Deadly Dinner are proven alternatives with high-quality physical materials and pre-made stories.
How much does a good murder mystery game cost?
Prices for murder mystery games vary by type: Crime & Dine .io as the only AI generator costs from €11.96 (for 4 players), classic digital content ranges from €19.99-€27.85, and box sets cost between €18.47 and €35. The price-performance ratio depends on individual requirements: box sets offer physical materials, digital content is more flexible, and AI generators enable personalization. All prices are starting prices based on current research (as of: November 2025).
What is the difference between box set and digital downloads?
Box sets contain pre-made stories with physical materials to unpack. Digital content are PDF files for downloading and printing - also pre-made.
New in the market: Crime & Dine .io is the first and currently only AI generator for murder mystery games. It creates personalized, unique games at the push of a button - each game is different. Available in German, English, French, and Spanish. Only Crime & Dine .io offers true personalization - all other providers (box sets and classic downloads) use pre-made stories that every customer gets the same.
Which murder mystery game is suitable for beginners?
Both are suitable for beginners: Culinario Mortale and Crime & Dine .io. Crime & Dine .io offers the possibility to choose the difficulty level yourself (complexity level) and creates all materials including game master guide, character sheets, and web app. Culinario Mortale offers proven, pre-made stories in a high-quality physical box - ideal for beginners who prefer a classic box.
Can you play murder mystery games multiple times?
Basically, no murder mystery game can be played multiple times with the same people, since everyone knows the solution. With pre-made games (box sets, downloads), you have to buy a completely new product for a new game. Crime & Dine .io, on the other hand, allows you to generate a completely new, different game for the same group at any time - each time a new story, new characters, new murderer!
Conclusion: Our Comparison 2025
After our comparison of all 10 providers: Each provider has its strengths. Crime & Dine .io is the first and only AI generator for murder mystery games and thus offers unique personalization. Available in German, English, French, and Spanish. Culinario Mortale and Deadly Dinner convince with high-quality physical materials and proven stories. Cocolino is unbeatable for very large groups (up to 60 people). Masters of Mystery and krimidinner.party are ideal for online formats via Zoom.
Which provider fits you?
- • Personalization: Crime & Dine .io (only AI generator)
- • Physical box with tactile materials: Culinario Mortale, Deadly Dinner, Kosmos
- • Very large groups (15+ people): Cocolino (up to 60 players)
- • Online via Zoom: Masters of Mystery, krimidinner.party
- • Premium with audio CD: Mörderische Dinnerparty
- • Large selection of themes: KRIMI total (23 games)
Interested in a personalized murder mystery game?
Create Murder Mystery Game Now - from €11.96Generated in 15 minutes • For 4-10 players • Individually personalized